Monthly Market Commentary – April 2025

What We Know for Sure: How Uncertainty Distorts Decision-Making

Geopolitical risk is grabbing headlines again. In today’s investment climate, it’s tempting to fixate on the big geopolitical question marks: Will Trump’s policies unseat the US dollar as the global reserve currency? How far will China go in asserting regional / global dominance? Can Europe hold its fragile unity? These are captivating storylines, but they come with a trap—they’re unknowable. For advisers guiding clients through volatility, the smarter conversation is not about what might happen, but what we know is already true.

And what we know is this: uncertainty has real economic costs, but its effects don’t always translate predictably into markets. Markets don’t always behave the way we’d expect.

The Real Cost of Uncertainty

When the policy environment becomes unpredictable—when rules change abruptly, processes are bypassed, or institutions lose their footing—companies hesitate. Long-term investment plans are postponed. Hiring slows. Supply chains are re-evaluated. The decision to locate production in one country over another might hinge not on cost, but on clarity and consistency of regulation. Companies don’t stop because they’re pessimistic. They stop because they can’t model the future.

This is not hypothetical. The chart below shows the Global Economic Policy Uncertainty Index, which has surged to unprecedented highs recently, surpassing even the peaks of the global financial crisis and the COVID pandemic. These are not isolated blips; they reflect sustained anxiety over trade tensions, geopolitical fragmentation, and unpredictable policy shifts. Studies by the Federal Reserve and the IMF have shown that investment spending slows sharply when policy uncertainty rises.

Figure 1: Global Economic Policy Uncertainty Index

Source: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/GEPUCURRENT

It’s not just about tariffs or taxes; it’s about whether the rules of the game will still apply next year. Consumers, too, respond to policy fog by tightening their belts. They delay buying homes or cars. They stay in their jobs longer. The cumulative effect of deferred decisions can quietly sap growth from the real economy.

Institutions Matter More Than Forecasts

If we can’t forecast policy, what can we trust? The strength of institutions.

Independent central banks, predictable legal systems, and transparent regulatory processes are not exciting headline topics—but they’re the foundations of investor confidence. They reduce uncertainty by anchoring expectations, even when the political cycle is noisy.

This is why investors differentiate sharply between countries that have robust institutions and those that don’t. It’s not just about GDP or debt levels; it’s about trust in the system. Strong institutions turn ambiguity into risk—something markets can price. Weak institutions turn it into uncertainty—something they can’t. Credibility, not just numbers, matters.

Arbitrariness Is More Damaging Than Bad Policy

Ironically, even bad policy can be better than arbitrary policy. Poor decisions can be modelled, priced, and accounted for. Arbitrariness cannot. When companies feel that decisions are driven by personalities, short-term political pressure, or opaque backchannels, they lose the ability to plan.

This is as true for global multinationals as it is for mid-sized firms trying to navigate cross-border operations or shifting tax codes. The drag on capital expenditure, hiring, and innovation is not ideological—it’s operational. Uncertainty doesn’t discriminate.

Wall Street Is Not High Street

But here’s the paradox: even when uncertainty drags on the real economy, markets may shrug—or even rally.

Why?

Because markets are forward-looking. They don’t trade on how the real economy feels today; they trade on how it might evolve six, twelve, or twenty-four months from now. Sometimes they anticipate a policy breakthrough. Sometimes they expect a rate cut. Sometimes, frankly, they just have too much liquidity chasing too few assets.

This disconnect between High Street and Wall Street can be confounding. A company may be cutting jobs while its share price soars. A country may be in recession while its stock market hits all-time highs. These are not contradictions—they’re reflections of different timeframes, different incentives, and different mechanisms of price discovery.

For advisers, the lesson is not to ignore the economy, but to recognise that understanding it does not automatically yield insight into markets. Clients who believe that “the bad news hasn’t hit the market yet” may not realise that markets already priced it—or have chosen to look past it.

The Adviser’s Role: Framing, Not Forecasting

This is where the adviser becomes indispensable—not for predicting the next twist in monetary policy or geopolitics, but for helping clients frame their decisions appropriately.

What do we know?

• Uncertainty tends to reduce real-world investment appetite.
• Strong institutions reduce uncertainty and support long-term confidence.
• Markets can rally even when the economy is soft—because they’re forward-looking.
• Composure and diversification remain the strongest defences against arbitrary shocks.

Trying to “trade” uncertainty is a fool’s errand. Building a strategy that acknowledges it, adapts to it, and remains robust through it—that’s a different story.

Conclusion: Stick to the Plan

In uncertain times, there is often a hunger for certainty. But the wise investor—and the wise adviser—knows that chasing certainty is not the same as managing risk.

The client who reads today’s headlines and wants to change their portfolio is not irrational—they’re human. The adviser who can separate story from signal, speculation from structure, isn’t just delivering performance, they’re delivering perspective, adding value far beyond the latest market update.

The takeaway is not to disengage from the world—but to interpret it more intelligently. We don’t need to know how the story ends to know how to stay in character.

Stay composed. Stay invested. Stay strategic.

LOCAL DRIVERS
VAT Hike Suspended

The high court’s suspension of the proposed VAT increase has triggered questions around the Treasury’s credibility and the cohesion of the GNU. Finance minister Godongwana’s backpedaling on the VAT hike, after earlier signalling commitment, has deepened investor concers over fiscal consistency and policy follow-through. The ANC has since called for a more structured approach to GNU decision-making, highlighting cracks in the ruling alliance. Consumer confidence plunged to multi-year lows, and the Rand remains vulnerable amid continued political and fiscal ambuguity.

Rate-Cut Bets Rise as Inflation Falls to Five Year Low

Headline inflation eased sharply, prompting traders to ramp up expectations of a SARB rate cut. With CPI now at its lowest level in nearly five years and the private sector in a protracted slowdown, calls for monetary easing have grown louder. However, SARB Governor Kganyago remains cautious, citing global risks and domestic vulnerabilities including load shedding and tariff impacts. Retail sales and mining data both disappointed, and leading indicators signal a deteriorating growth backdrop despite improved trade data and firmer reserves from elevated gold prices

Growth Forecasts Cut Amid Structural and External Pressures

South Africa’s 2025 GDP growth projections have been revised downward by several institutions. The IMF now forecasts 1.0% growth, down from 1.5%, citing escalating U.S. trade tariffs and global uncertainty. The South African Reserve Bank (SARB) adjusted its estimate to 1.7%, acknowledging subdued demand and persistent supply-side constraints. Private sector analysts, including Moody’s and the Bureau for Economic Research, have also lowered their forecasts to approximately 1.5% . These revisions reflect ongoing challenges: weak business confidence, high unemployment, and underperforming industrial sectors. While inflation has eased, offering potential for monetary policy support, structural issues continue to hinder robust economic recovery.

ASSET CLASS TOTAL RETURNS – ZAR
GLOBAL DRIVERS
US Economy Contracts Amid Tariff Pressures

The U.S. economy contracted by 0.3% in Q1 2025, marking the first decline since early 2022. This unexpected downturn was primarily driven by a surge in imports as businesses and consumers accelerated purchases ahead of new tariffs introduced by President Trump, leading to a significant trade deficit. While consumer spending and business investments provided some offsets, economists warn of potential further weakening throughout the year. The Federal Reserve maintained interest rates at 4.25% to 4.5%, citing concerns over inflation and the economic impact of ongoing trade tensions

Eurozone Growth Surpasses Expectations

The Eurozone economy grew by 0.4% in Q1 2025, doubling the previous quarter’s pace and exceeding forecasts. Ireland and Spain led the growth, while Germany and France showed modest recoveries. However, the introduction of U.S. tariffs poses significant risks to future growth, with early indicators suggesting a potential slowdown in the coming quarters

Global Trade Disruption Peaks, but Trump Softens Rhetoric

April marked the most volatile phase yet of Trump’s trade war, with tariffs imposed across nearly all major partners — China, EU, UK, and parts of Asia. However, late in the month, Trump surprised markets by floating a substantial rollback on China tariffs in exchange for a new trade deal, citing economic risks. Equities initially sold off but later rebounded as the VIX recorded a historic plunge. The flip-flop in U.S. trade policy has created whiplash across global markets, with companies, central banks, and policymakers scrambling to adapt to the unpredictability

ASSET CLASS TOTAL RETURNS – USD
Global Review, Investment Advisory, Investments, Market Commentary, Markets, Wealth Management

SHARE THIS ARTICLE